Just to clear the air — this is all in good fun! One Piece is a masterpiece, and Enies Lobby is one of the best arcs of all time. We’re just trolling a little. Let’s dive into what fans playfully consider the “worst arc” in the series.
One Piece, the legendary manga and anime series created by Eiichiro Oda, has captivated fans for over two decades. From epic battles to tear-jerking backstories and jaw-dropping world-building, the story of Luffy and the Straw Hat Pirates has redefined modern shonen.
However, no long-running series is without its weaker points—or rather, fan-declared least favorite arcs. Over the years, fans have debated which arc deserves the title of the “worst.” Some entries might surprise you.
Defining “Worst”: A Matter of Perspective
Before anyone grabs their pitchforks, it’s important to note that labeling an arc as the “worst” in One Piece is incredibly subjective.
In a show that has over 1000 episodes and dozens of arcs, some will naturally feel slower or less impactful when compared to heavy-hitters like Marineford, Enies Lobby, or Wano.
Most “worst arc” designations come down to:
- Pacing issues
- Filler content
- Lack of emotional stakes
- Weak antagonists
- Low animation quality in the anime adaptation
With that in mind, let’s look at some arcs fans frequently call out—and why.
The Arc Most Commonly Labeled “Worst”: The Foxy Pirate Arc (Davy Back Fight)
Fan Reception
The Foxy Pirate Arc, also known as the Davy Back Fight, often tops polls and Reddit threads asking fans for their least favorite arc. Despite being canon, it feels like a long filler episode wedged awkwardly between Skypiea and Water 7—two extremely plot-rich arcs.
Why Fans Dislike It
- Tonal Shift: Coming off the dramatic high of Skypiea, the Davy Back Fight feels like slapstick comedy overload.
- Foxy as an Antagonist: While hilarious at times, Foxy lacks the menace of more serious villains.
- Stakes Are… Silly: Competing in games to win or lose crew members isn’t exactly the One Piece standard of epic conflict.
- Extended Gags: Many fans felt the comedy dragged too long, making the arc feel like a chore.
Related YouTube Shorts Reactions
To see what fans are saying in video form, check out these short but hilarious reactions about the Foxy arc:
These videos show exactly why people roast this arc—but also why it still holds a special place in the fandom.
Other Contenders for “Worst Arc” (According to Fan Feedback)
1. Long Ring Long Land (Anime Version)
While this is technically part of the Foxy arc, the anime added extra filler content, slowing the pace and frustrating many fans. The “stretch” of episodes makes rewatching feel tedious.
2. Post-Alabasta Filler Arc
This anime-only arc shows the crew’s personal reflections via flashbacks. While emotionally touching, it lacks progression.
3. Warship Island Arc (Anime-Only)
The first filler arc in the anime is nostalgic for some, but universally considered skippable. It feels disconnected from the main plot and lacks the polish of later filler arcs like G-8.
What About Enies Lobby? (Spoiler: It’s Not the Worst at All)
Let’s be clear: Enies Lobby is peak fiction. The emotional weight, pacing, and stakes are all phenomenal. This blog is just having a little fun by “trolling” the idea.
From Robin’s iconic line to the intense fights with CP9, Enies Lobby deserves its place at the top of every One Piece tier list.
Fan Polls and Reddit Threads: What Are Fans Saying?
Across community discussions, the following arcs get the most “least favorite” votes:
- Foxy’s Davy Back Fight Arc
- Warship Island (filler)
- Post-Alabasta
- Fishman Island (due to pacing—not story)
Even these arcs have value and moments worth watching, but they simply don’t resonate with everyone the same way.
The G-8 Exception: Filler Gold
The G-8 Arc proves filler can be fantastic when it respects the series’ tone and character dynamics. It’s considered one of the best filler arcs in anime, and many fans rewatch it with enthusiasm.
Final Thoughts: There Are No Truly Bad Arcs
One Piece is a story told over generations. Some arcs will be slow, others absurd—but they all contribute to the larger journey. Even the so-called “worst arc” is better than the best moments in many other anime.
TL;DR:
- Worst Arc by fan consensus? Foxy’s Davy Back Fight
- Enies Lobby? GOAT. Don’t even debate it
- Watch fan reactions for some laughs
- Even “bad” arcs help shape the Straw Hat adventure
No Comments